For as long as i've been interested in politics (about 10yrs i think, since that May 1st landslide...) these are 2 themes that surround the particular brand of democracy served up in the UK.
And now that counting is finished in elections for 600 local council seats in England, 129 Parliamentary seats in Scotland and 60 Assembly seats in Wales, both themes are there again for all to see.
The cynics have found plenty to moan about, here's just a selection:
- Problems with new voting systems in Scotland must be part of a government conspiracy to rob some people of their vote (I'm saying nothing about people who are too stupid to follow instructions and their right to vote...)
- The usual (& tired) 'all parties are offering the same, so i'm not voting' argument
- The BBC is biased in its reporting (it was used accused of bias against each of the 2 main parties, in separate comments to the same post on its 'Election 07 blog' - now surely that's proof of neutrality!)
- And my personal favourite, again a comment on the same blog posting: "I personally have never been represented by anyone I have voted for in 24 years of participating in 'democracy'"
This poor guy. Despite being one of only 60 million people in the country, noone has ever given him exactly what he wants. Next time they should give him a specially marked ballot paper, so his choice will be guaranteed to win...
I prefer not to focus on the cynicism, i prefer to celebrate the choice and the way it was exercised. For example, that voter turnout increased across the whole country.
But to me, the best statistic of them all is one that i haven't seen reported anywhere (actually i had to count it myself to be able to write about it...) It's the gross number of seats that changed hands in the elections. In England alone it stands at 74 out of 309 for which results are in - or 24%. I recently read that the true sign of democracy is not how you vote people in, but how easy it is to vote them out when you're not happy. In England this week, this right was exercised in 1 in every 4 seats that was up for election.
Whatever the cynics may say, and whatever the small details that still need to be worked out with new voting systems in Scotland & Wales, i think this shows democracy is still in full swing on those strange islands in the North of Europe...